Brouhaha

I’ve intentionally restrained myself from participation in the whole #Kony2012 brouhaha for several reasons, one of which is simply that I was busy with other things. Another is that I wanted to sort of let things simmer down a bit so that I could speak, rather than holler over the din of said brouhaha. The by now famous video to which I cannot bring myself to direct even one single additional hit (so you’ll just have to Google it), leaves us in the humanitarian world with a number of interesting takeaways, in my opinion.

For me, the first and most important is:

Long, involved messaging works. Or at least it can. Whatever else you want to say about Kony 2012, the fact that the supposed “most viral video of all time” is but a few moments short of 30 minutes long has huge implication for how we can now think about marketing our work and educating the general public about what we do. After a decades-long career of being told that donor education and marketing messaging had to be condensed into mere seconds, 30 minutes to get a point across – thirty minutes! – feels like a dream come true.

There’s no excuse to fall back on oversimplification of humanitarian issues.

 

There’s also the point that…

Humanitarians have done a very poor job at helping their constituent audiences formulate linkages between activism and action. This is not a new problem, but Kony 2012 re-hits us over the head with it. Nearly 100 million viewers still have no concrete sense of what options there might be for dealing with Kony (the filmmakers’ own son obliquely suggests war, or maybe assassination?), or what the ramifications of the various options might be. Nor do they have any clear sense of what they can do individually, beyond wear a bracelet and send money to an organization that few had even heard of prior.

Even the mighty Kristof in defending Kony 2012 against criticism from the humanitarian world (“nobody fights more wickedly than humanitarians…”) cannot get more specific about what this film accomplishes than some nebulous statements about “galvanizing concern among mostly young Americans.”  Oversimplification of the issues is a critical problem as others have repeatedly pointed out (so well that I don’t have to ), but in the end my strongest personal grievance with Kony 2012 is simply that it doesn’t tell us what needs to happen. Write a letter to my senator? Saying what, exactly? Join the army?

Joseph Kony is a bad man who needs to be ‘stopped.’ I agree. But how?

 

We need to be careful to not blur the distinction between raising awareness about a problem, and the capability of humanitarians to address it. Kony 2012 is only the latest shining example of awareness-raising about a problem that is utterly beyond the capability of the humanitarian community to address. We can work with former child soldiers (very specialized, by the way, and extremely difficult. Few NGOs or individuals have the ability to do this properly.), we can engage in different ways on the periphery, we can do “advocacy” in the Humanitarian Capitals… and that’s kind of it. As NGOs and as humanitarians, we cannot stop Kony. Or restore law and order and safety in Somalia. Or Darfur. Or Afghanistan.

In broad principle I completely agree that more awareness among the general population about issues such as the evil being inflicted by the LRA, the better. But as those who on a regular basis raise that awareness, we need to be conscientious to couple awareness-raising with sound messaging about what real solutions might look like. And also with clear statements about what role we as humanitarians might play in bringing about those solutions.

 

Finally…

Beware the meteoric rise: When an organization or cause or movement is based on a single charismatic individual who rockets to fame overnight, it almost never ends well. Enough said.

About these ads
Leave a comment

8 Comments

  1. T

     /  March 21, 2012

    Thanks for adding to the brouhaha, J. ;)
    Although, I do wonder how many people actually watched ALL 30 minutes of the video…

    Reply
  2. Thank you J.

    That is an exceptionally sensible and well written post.

    Reply
  3. Actually, YouTube counts everyone who *starts* the video as a viewer, no matter whether they watched 30 minutes or 30 seconds. I’d love to see stats how many people have actually finished the video. I’m sure the number is still impressive, but the 100 million we have been hearing is certainly inflated.

    Reply
  4. Great post J. Nice to read you again :)
    If the focus of the film would have been on Jacob’s life or other children affected by the conflict, it would have given space to amplify their voices, their viewpoints and understanding of the situation. That would have been a much better advocacy tool, while also giving them space to share their stories.

    Reply
  1. Our part in the Kony 2012 narrative « lindsey talerico.
  2. Advocacy and Advertisements | Engineer Without Borders
  3. Brouhaha | Global Health Hub: news and blogosphere aggregator
  4. What Aid Workers Want | AidSpeak

Share your thoughts...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  • Take the aid and development worker survey!

  • Check out my latest humanitarian novel!

  • Instagram

    "Naturally caffeine free." After three days of wondering why "this coffee doesn't seem to be working," I finally read the label. #coffee #facepalm #expatfail #travel #Jordan Carbing up in #Amman #Jordan #MiddleEast #travel One of these has good head-retention #airportpurgatory #travel #Frankfurt #Germany #airportpurgatory #travel About half-done #homebrew #beer #amber #ale Boonkhathin #SriSaket #Thailand #Issan #latergram #travel 1992
  • Your email address goes here....

  • Recent Posts

  • Categories

  • Archives

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 237 other followers

%d bloggers like this: