Times, they are a-changin’

There’s a good chance that unless you’ve been intentionally following what has come to be affectionately known in some circles as Three-Cups-of-Tea-gate, you missed this update on the KPLU website (KPLU is a local NPR affiliate based in Seattle, WA):

‘Three Cups of Tea’ and ‘deceit’ has international aid in hot spotlight.

It’s not a long article, but for those not motivated to click the link and read all of it, basically it is a short update on the status of the civil lawsuit being brought against Greg Mortenson, his co-author David Relin, the Penguin Group, and the Central Asia Institute. The language of the accusation is particularly telling: the defendants (Mortenson, Relin, Penguin and CAI) are being accused of fraud and racketeering. ¬†At the same time the States Attorney for the state of Montana is pursuing a full investigation of the Central Asia Institute to see whether it broke state laws which govern the actions of non-profit organizations there.

Much is made in the article of the similarities between Mortenson and James Frey who was convicted of fraud and forced to pay reparations after admitting on the Oprah Winfrey show that he’d lied in what was marketed as his memoir, A Million Little Pieces. And predictably, Mortenson’s attorneys want the civil suit against him thrown out because,

“Plaintiffs should not be allowed to create a world where authors are exposed to the debilitating expense of class action litigation just because someone believes a book contains inaccuracies,”

I’m no attorney myself and so cannot really have more than a layperson’s perspective on the legalities at play here. But it seems to me that this is both representative of a now almost complete shift in public perception of aid organizations and aid workers, and also a portent of tougher times headed for the aid industry. Regardless of one’s personal perspective on Greg Mortenson and Three Cups of Tea and the Central Asia Institute, and even if this particular lawsuit is lost, we are now living in a time when donors can and will take us to court if they can make the case that we painted a picture in our marketing and PR which did not convey reality.

Those of you who work for an NGO that markets or fundraises in the United States, take a close look at your employer’s fundraising material and ask yourself how it makes you feel, knowing what you know about the real world of implementing humanitarian relief and development in the field. I don’t mean to say that the house of cards will come crashing down tomorrow. But the sea has changed.

We’re working in a strange, new time.

About these ads
Previous Post
Leave a comment

4 Comments

  1. Ash S

     /  February 13, 2012

    I can see you point J, and it might be the start of a slippery slope but there’s a long way to go between institutional fundraising documents, where the nature of the documents are clear and so expected to present the organisation’s work in a favourable light.

    Mortenson on the other hand based his fundraising on this single-person narrative making a much stronger claim to accurate representation. Also there were far more ‘facts’ in his book than you would find in the average fundraising email from an institution.

    I’d say this is where the outrage comes in, that it was unacceptable misrepresentation given the nature of the document which was presented as fact. The moral of the story might just be not to write books with artistic licence that you claim as fact and then use as a fundraising tool, rather than a fundamental change to how we could do fundraising. But I guess we’ll see.

    Reply
  2. This seems to be a story more about the personal mission of one man to fulfil his Jesus complex rather than an indicator of organisations being held to account. I know some orgs have this sort of personalised, look-at-the-wonderful-things-our-dear-leader-has-done, kind of message (I’ve worked for one) but, personally, I wouldn’t work for one again. Would any, more experienced humanitarian workers disagree on that? Why?

    Reply
  3. Thanks for the update.

    Reply
  1. Pencils of Promise | Wanderlustress

Share your thoughts...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  • Take the aid and development worker survey!

  • Check out my latest humanitarian novel!

  • Instagram

    Carbing up in #Amman #Jordan #MiddleEast #travel One of these has good head-retention #airportpurgatory #travel #Frankfurt #Germany #airportpurgatory #travel About half-done #homebrew #beer #amber #ale Boonkhathin #SriSaket #Thailand #Issan #latergram #travel 1992 #DoloAdo airport #Ethiopia #hum #aid #latergram #travel 2012
  • Your email address goes here....

  • Recent Posts

  • Categories

  • Archives

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 236 other followers

%d bloggers like this: